Fisher Island Club members and guests dine on gourmet and casual cuisine in the varied ambiance of the island's restaurants and lounges.
- The Vanderbilt Mansion is the Fisher Island Club's formal restaurant and offers fine dining in two intimate rooms, Napoleon-era lounges and drawing rooms. For private gatherings up to 150 guests can be accommodated in elegant, high-ceiling rooms with crystal chandeliers.
- Fronting a mile-long private beach, the ocean-side Beach Club serves casual fare indoors and out in a relaxed island atmosphere.
- Inspired by a superb restaurant in Costa Smeralda, Sardinia, Cafe Porto Cervo serves exquisite Italian and Mediterranean cuisine, with many dishes prepared over a mesquite fire.
- Situated overlooking one of the marinas, La Trattoria offers delicious homemade pasta and pizza in a casual atmosphere.
- Located within the Golf Club House, the Golf Grill offers casual dining inside or outside on the terrace.
- Created as an intimate theater, Cafe Tangier hosts dinners, plays, shows, speakers and other events for members throughout the year.